Prof. Dr. Hüseyin Bağcı Analyzes the Escalating Middle East Tensions on Iran-Israel and Lebanon
On October 3, 2024, Prof. Dr. Hüseyin Bağcı, co-founder of Ankara Global Advisory Group, attended as a distinguished speaker on Habertürk TV’s Türkiye'nin Nabzı program, presented by Fevzi Çakır. Prof. Dr. Bağcı provided profound insights into the ongoing conflicts in the Middle East, particularly focusing on the volatile situation between Israel and Lebanon. His analysis offers a comprehensive understanding of the geopolitical dynamics at play and the potential ramifications for regional stability.
Key Insights from Prof. Dr. Hüseyin Bağcı:
Lebanon could become Israel’s Vietnam: Prof. Dr. Bağcı drew a parallel between Lebanon and Vietnam, questioning whether Lebanon could become "Israel's Vietnam." He highlighted the historical context of the Vietnam War, emphasizing the long-term economic and educational ties that emerged post-conflict. This comparison serves to illustrate the potential long-term consequences if Israel intensifies its military involvement in Lebanon, potentially leading to prolonged instability and international repercussions similar to those experienced in Vietnam.
Lack of Political Will for Peace: A critical point raised by Prof. Dr. Bağcı is the absence of genuine political will among key parties—Hezbollah, Israel, and Hamas—to pursue lasting peace. He underscored that without a committed desire from these groups to coexist peacefully, diplomatic efforts are likely to remain ineffective. This entrenched stance impedes any meaningful negotiations and perpetuates the cycle of violence and retaliation in the region.
Turkey’s Diplomatic Efforts and Challenges: Prof. Dr. Bağcı acknowledged Turkey's proactive role in facilitating peace talks, notably with Somalia. However, he pointed out the significant challenges arising from divergent interests among conflicting parties. The complexity of aligning these interests underscores the difficulties Turkey faces in mediating effective and sustainable peace agreements in the Middle East, especially in regions with fragile or non-existent central governments like Lebanon and Syria.
Iran’s Influence and Strategic Limitations: Examining Iran's role, Prof. Dr. Bağcı explained that Iran exerts substantial influence across several Middle Eastern countries, including Iraq, Syria, and Lebanon. However, he cautioned that Iran's capacity to stabilize these regions is limited due to the absence of strong central governments. Furthermore, he highlighted the strained relations between Iran and the Western world, exacerbated by long-standing economic and military embargoes, which constrain Iran’s ability to act as a stabilizing force in Lebanon or Syria.
International Diplomacy and Geopolitical Maneuvering: Prof. Dr. Bağcı emphasized the ongoing diplomatic engagements by major powers such as the United States, Iran, and European nations with Israel. He noted that despite these efforts, tangible progress towards peace remains elusive. The continuous diplomatic dialogues reflect the complex interplay of international interests and the challenges in aligning these diverse agendas towards a unified approach to conflict resolution in the Middle East.
Escalation Risks and Potential for Wider Conflict: Addressing the immediate threats, Prof. Dr. Bağcı warned of the imminent risk of military escalation between Israel and Hezbollah in Lebanon. He detailed recent small-scale attacks and the potential for these to spiral into larger conflicts, possibly drawing in regional and global powers. This scenario poses a significant threat to international stability, with the possibility of transforming a regional conflict into a global confrontation.
Violation of International Law and Ethical Concerns: Prof. Dr. Bağcı criticized Israel’s actions, asserting that they constitute violations of international law and harm global ethical standards. He referenced the substantial loss of civilian lives in Lebanon, Palestine, and Gaza as evidence of policies that disregard international norms. This stance not only damages Israel’s global standing but also undermines the integrity of international law in addressing and resolving conflicts.
Conclusion: The Region will Continue to Face Cycles of Instability as Political Will for Remains Low
In his concluding remarks, Prof. Dr. Hüseyin Bağcı emphasized that the future of the Israel-Lebanon conflict hinges on a delicate balance of regional power struggles and global diplomatic efforts. He argued that while Israel’s military actions may intensify, the absence of a strong political will for peace from both Israel and its adversaries makes the path to resolution highly uncertain. Moreover, Iran’s increasing influence, especially through proxy organizations, adds another layer of complexity. Prof. Bağcı underscored the importance of strategic diplomacy, as global powers like the U.S., Russia, and China work to prevent further escalation, but warned that without addressing the deeper political and ideological divides, the region will continue to face cycles of instability.
Ankara Global Advisory Group is proud to continue offering thought leadership on key international issues, ensuring that global decision-makers are equipped with the knowledge they need to navigate complex security dynamics.
For a more detailed analysis from Prof. Dr. Hüseyin Bağcı and the latest developments in international relations, continue following updates from Ankara Global Advisory Group.